Best Toaster Ovens of 2018

Linda Thomson ·
Updated
We maintain strict editorial integrity when we evaluate products and services; however, Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links.

We spent 80 hours testing and researching toaster ovens and determined the Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL was our top choice. Designed with nine preset cooking functions, this reasonably sized and powerful toaster oven can help you prepare a wide range of foods, from simply toasting bagels to preparing a full-sized Sunday roast. Its temperature settings were spot-on during our tests. When you open the door, a cooking rack automatically moves out by itself, reducing the risk of burns. The oven also shuts off automatically after each use, which is another great safety feature. 

Best Overall

Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL

The Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL toaster oven gives you nine preset cooking temperatures as well as manual temperature adjustment. It cooks evenly, can handle a full-sized roast and includes many safety features.
View on Amazon
Best Value

Oster Large Digital Countertop Oven TSSTTVMNDG-001

The Oster Large Digital Countertop Oven TSSTTVMNDG-001 has seven preset temperatures for quick setup. It is an energy-efficient model and lets you cook with both conventional and convection cooking methods.
View on Amazon
Best for Versatility

DeLonghi Digital Convection Toaster Oven DO1289

With a DeLonghi Digital Convection Toaster Oven DO1289, you get exceptional versatility. You can bake, broil, defrost and even make use of an included dehydrator kit with this unit.
View on Amazon

Our Test Results

Product
Price
Overall Rating
9.5
9.1
8.4
7.3
7.3
6.9
6
Performance
10
10
9.8
7
6.8
7.8
7
Design
8.5
8.8
8.5
7.5
8.5
4
3.8
Safety
10
8
7
8.5
6.3
9.3
7
Conveniences
10
9.5
7
4.8
7.8
6.8
7
Controls
Dial
Dial
Touchpad
Touchpad
Dial
Dial
Dial
Digital Display Screen
N/A
N/A
Infrared Heating
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Convection Fan
N/A
N/A
N/A
Bread Slice Capacity
6
6
6
4
6
6
4
Number of Racks
1
2
1
1
1
1
1
Warranty
1 Year
1 Year
1 Year
1 Year
2 Years
2 Years
1 Year
Handle Temperature (Fahrenheit)
79
84
93
107
88
85
80
Automatic Shut-Off
N/A
Exterior Temperature (Fahrenheit)
94
98
176
250
90
190
170
Automatic Rack Ejection
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Broiling Rack
N/A
N/A
Bake Pan
Cook Functions
9
8
7
6
6
4
3
Nonstick Interior
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Ease of Use Score
100%
82%
63%
73%
63%
63%
86%
Adjustable Racks
N/A
Pizza Pan
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Timer Limit (minutes)
120
120
90
25
120
None
30
Depth (inches)
16.25
15.2
18.1
12
13.78
14.63
11.25
Width (inches)
18.5
19
22.5
13
21.85
16.29
14
Weight (pounds)
17
14.7
20.3
7.5
20.95
12.9
7.2
Height (inches)
11.25
9.4
14.6
10.25
17.32
8.86
7.75
Defrost Setting
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Performance Score
100%
84%
84%
67%
75%
92%
80%
Preheat Time (minutes)
5:26
3:27
4:29
27:00
7:00
5:30
19:22
Temperature Range (Fahrenheit)
120-500
180-450
150-450
250-500
150-450
150-450
200-450
Wattage
1800
1400
1300
1300
1800
1800
1050
Best Overall

Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL

Despite its compact size, you can use the well-designed Breville Smart Oven BOV800XL like a second oven for cooking a variety of dishes. It comes with nine cooking settings: toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat and warm.
However, you can manually adjust the temperature between 120 and 500 degrees Fahrenheit. This is a powerful 1,800-watt countertop appliance, so it heats up quickly. You can easily adjust the cooking functions and the time and temperature using the dial controls and LCD display. You can adjust the wire cooking rack so you get it as close to the heating elements as you want, and the glass door gives you information about where to put the rack depending on what cooking setting you are using. This unit also comes with a baking pan, pizza pan and broiler rack. You can set its timer for two hours, but if you're cooking something longer than that, you'll need to adjust it. You get a non-stick interior with this convection toaster oven that makes it easy to clean. The Breville Smart Oven also provides some great safety features. The wire rack ejects itself automatically when you open the door, a nice safety feature. This toaster oven also shuts off after each use, which means you can worry a bit less about older children and teens cooking pizza or heating up snacks.
Pros
  • You get nine cooking settings.
  • The heating is even throughout the inside.
  • This unit preheats quickly.
Cons
  • It uses lots of electrical power.
  • This oven costs more than most models.
  • It has a one-year warranty.
$233.20Amazon
Best Value

Oster Large Digital Countertop Oven TSSTTVMNDG-001

The versatile Oster Large Digital Countertop Oven TSSTTVMNDG-001 performs well despite its low price. It can bake, broil and defrost plenty of different foods.
You get a total of seven preset cooking functions, including bake, convection bake, broil, warm and defrost. You also get preset toast and pizza functions. It comes with a wire rack, which you can adjust to different levels, and you get a 90-minute timer. It is also energy efficient, using only 1,300 watts. The baking temperature ranges from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, and the broil setting can get up to 450 degrees. Our testing for this toaster oven's thermostat revealed that the inside gets somewhat warmer than the temperature we set. This did not affect our test cooking results, but you should be aware of it if you plan to make something that requires flawless accuracy. This toaster oven gives you both conventional heating that surrounds food with heat and a convection bake option that uses a fan to circulate hot air, so you can vary cooking methods depending on what you're making. You program this unit with an easy-to-use touchpad and display screen. The Oster will automatically shut off after the time runs out, which is a fine safety feature. One drawback is that our testing showed the top of this toaster oven got rather hot at 176 degrees Fahrenheit; the sides and handle tested better at levels below 100 degrees.
Pros
  • You get an automatic shut-off function.
  • This is an inexpensive machine.
  • The touchpad controls are easy to use.
Cons
  • The interior is a little harder to clean.
  • The temperatures run somewhat high.
  • Our testing showed the top gets quite hot.
$67.01Amazon
Best for Versatility

DeLonghi Digital Convection Toaster Oven DO1289

You get exceptional versatility with the DeLonghi Digital Convection Toaster Oven DO1289 that not only lets you cook foods in a number of ways, but also comes with a dehydrator kit so you can preserve foods. In our testing, this countertop appliance routinely preheated faster than any other model we tested.
This multi-purpose appliance offers eight regular cooking functions – and eight settings just for pizza. You get two tiers inside, so you can cook two different foods at the same time using the wire racks included in your purchase. This toaster oven uses only 1,400 watts, which is quite energy efficient. With the bake, broil and defrost settings, you can change the oven heat from 180 to 145 degrees Fahrenheit. However, when we set the DeLonghi for 350 degrees, it got to 390 and went a bit higher, which means you could end up with a burnt dinner. You might need to check this toaster oven periodically while using it. However, we did find that all the food we tested ended up evenly and properly cooked. This compact toaster oven features automatic shut-off at the end of a cooking cycle, which reduces the potential for fires. Unfortunately, it does not have an automatic rack ejector, so you have to manually pull out the racks, which is a potential burn risk. This toaster oven maintains cool temperatures on the outside while operating at 350 degrees Fahrenheit. We tested several areas on the outside that measured under 100 degrees, and the handle only reached 84 degrees, which is fine. However, while most of the unit remained cool, the back of the oven reached over 300 degrees, so you will want to leave space behind the unit so it doesn’t create a possible fire hazard.
Pros
  • You get exceptional versatility in cooking methods.
  • You can use conventional or convection cooking.
  • It has an automatic shut-off capability.
Cons
  • Interior temperatures can get hotter than you want.
  • You don't get an automatic rack ejector.
  • The oven's back exterior gets hot.
$200.30Amazon

Why Trust Us? 

Top Ten Reviews has been testing, researching, and ranking kitchen appliances since 2010. After we research a wide range of products within a category and learn as much as we can about the products, we narrow the field. We then test several of the products in our test lab using our own methodology and keep careful notes. After that, we score them using a proprietary system that helps determine which products to include in our list and what their ranking should be.

How We Tested 

We spent 80 hours testing, researching and evaluating toaster ovens for performance, design, safety and convenience features. Among other things, we tested for temperature precision and ranges, as well as evenness, since that makes an enormous difference in how certain foods turn out. We tested how hot these countertop devices got on the outside since low temperatures guard against accidental burns. We checked how easy it was to program the timers and displays and noted whether they had manual dials or touchpad controls.

To gauge accuracy, we set all the toaster ovens to 350 degrees and measured how long it took to reach that temperature and tested whether the interior temperature matched our setting. These temperatures varied by 5 to 10 degrees on half the models we tested, and on the other half we sometimes found a dismaying difference of 50 degrees or more. We gave the highest marks to toaster ovens that stayed close to the temperatures we set.

Of course, with toaster ovens we cooked a number of foods. To check how evenly heat was distributed, we put bread slices along the entire rack in each oven and made toast. We found that most of the ovens toasted the bread to the desired shade and that each piece cooked the same amount, indicating that almost every toaster oven cooks evenly.

We also tested three different types of food to see how each toaster oven managed with raw, frozen and reheated foods. For raw food, we made cookies. There was some variation on how well done the cookies were. The low-priced models tended to bake the cookies far more than our standards and taste buds required, while the high-priced units baked cookies to our satisfaction. We tested burritos and pizzas for the frozen and reheated foods. All of the toaster ovens performed similarly, making thoroughly cooked dishes with good texture and flavor.

Things to Look for in a Toaster Oven 

Performance
To help you make the best choice for your household, we tested ovens extensively to see how quickly they preheated, how they performed at 350 degrees Fahrenheit, how hot the interior and exterior got, and how well they cooked a variety of foods. Great performance involves consistent temperatures, even heating, a reasonably cool exterior and, most important of all, properly cooked food.

Design
To decide which toaster oven is best for you, consider the type of cooking you do and the size of your countertop. Some people love dial controls, but others might prefer touchpad controls. Most of the toaster ovens we tested can fit six slices of bread inside, while a few can only handle four slices. The larger toaster ovens can handle a medium pizza, while the four-slice toaster ovens can only cook a small pizza. Depending on how you like to cook, you might want to look for other useful features including the number and type of preset cook functions, built-in timers and adjustable racks.

Safety
If you have older children and teens using the toaster oven, safety features are especially important. Only a handful of toaster ovens have automatic rack ejection, which helps prevent burned fingertips and hands, because you don't have to reach into a small, hot oven to slide the rack out. Other things that can play a big part in your choice are the presence of an automatic shut-off function, how well the toaster oven retains heat and the exterior temperature.

id:1240