Best Online Check Ordering Services of 2018

Billy Bommer ·
Writer/Reviewer
Updated
We maintain strict editorial integrity when we evaluate products and services; however, Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links.

We researched and compared the top 10 online check ordering services that help you customize your personal and business checks. CheckAdvantage is the best online ordering service for most people because it has thousands of check design options and the strongest security features. You can personalize your checks with photos, monograms and various fonts, or choose from a library of popular themes like nature, sports, animation and floral. CheckAdvantage makes ordering checks for yourself or your business worry-free by hand-checking your order before they ship it.     

Best Overall

CheckAdvantage

CheckAdvantage has 2,500 custom designs and guarantees your money back if your check order is printed incorrectly or isn’t shipped on time.
Best Value

Carousel Checks

You can get a box of standard wallet checks from Carousel Checks for less than $6. That is the best price we found for a simple box of checks.
Worth Considering

Checks In The Mail

Checks In The Mail has hundreds of popular designs, including Star Wars, Spiderman and Snoopy themes. It also has important security features to keep your account safe.

Our Test Results

Product
Price
Overall Rating
9.7
9.5
9.3
8.9
8.6
8.2
8
7.9
Customization Options
10
9.4
9.5
8.1
8.1
5.6
8.1
9.4
Check Styles & Add-Ons
10
10
10
10
9.4
10
6.3
6.3
Security
10
10
10
9.4
10
10
10
10
Help & Support
8.1
8.1
6.3
8.1
6.3
8.1
8.1
5
Ink Stamps
Side-Tear Checks
Deposit Tickets
Business Checks Available
Laser, High Security, Manual
Laser, High Security, Manual
Laser, High Security, Manual
Laser, High Security, Manual
Laser, High Security, Manual
Laser, High Security, Manual
None
None
Top Stub
N/A
Virtual Checks
N/A
N/A
Single Wallet Checks
Check Register
Duplicate Copy
Box of Single Checks
$7.50
$6.99
$5.49
Not Specified
$7.46
$18.99
$18.99
$19.95
Back Security Screen
Safety Paper
Microprint
CPSA Member
Security Measures
100%
100%
100%
90%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Chemical Protection
Popular Themes
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Limited Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Limited Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Animated, Nature, Sports, Floral
Custom Checkbook Covers
N/A
Design Selection
2,500
300
1,250
80
136
70
200
800
Stock Logos
Personalization
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Photos, Monogram & Fonts
Product Catalog
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Live Chat
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Money-Back Guarantee
N/A
N/A
Quick Reorder
Email & Phone Support
FAQs
Best Overall
CheckAdvantage has unique design options created by independent licensed artists. You can choose from more than 300 check covers to complement your check pattern. You can also select a custom font.
This online check ordering service does not offer many well-known characters, so you may want to consider a different product if you want an image of a popular superhero or cartoon character on your checks. CheckAdvantage allows small-business owners to add their logo to their business checks. This company also offers payroll computer checks that are compatible with Quicken, QuickBooks, Microsoft Money, Great Plains and Peachtree accounting software. You can purchase business checks in a package that includes a deposit record and an endorsement stamp. If you prefer to hand-write checks instead of using accounting software, CheckAdvantage has three-on-a-page manual checks that come in top-stub or side-tear formats. If you aren’t pleased with the print quality or timeliness of shipping from CheckAdvantage, they offer a money-back guarantee. Each order is hand-checked to make sure your bank and personal information is correct.
Pros
  • 2,500 design options
  • CPSA-compliant
  • Money-back guarantee
Cons
  • Very few popular character options
  • No product catalog for browsing offline
  • Expensive
Best Value
If you want a simple box of single checks for the best price, Carousel Checks is your best bet. Each box contains 125 checks and costs less than $6. The design options and security features are limited, but this company has some of the most competitive prices for every category of design and security. This is one of the few services in our comparison that doesn’t include check registers and deposit tickets with every check order.
Carousel Checks has the second-largest design catalog in our comparison, with 1,250 options. There aren’t many popular characters from the movie or television industry, but the design options are categorized by theme, including value checks, floral themes, scenic designs, and “fun and games” checks. Carousel also has a good selection of business checks. You can choose from a catalog of laser checks for use with accounting software like Quicken or QuickBooks, or manual checks with various stub options. They also have a good selection of accessories, so you can add a custom checkbook cover.
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • 1,250 design options
  • High-security personal and business checks
Cons
  • Check register and deposit tickets not included
  • No live chat support
  • Limited popular character designs
Worth Considering
Checks In The Mail offers more than 300 design options, including popular themes from movies like “Star Wars,” “Minions” and “Frozen.”
The company also has high-security checks for business and personal accounts. Reordering is simplified with a Quick Reorder tab at the top of the company’s website. This company rewards bulk buyers with a discount and includes deposit slips and a transaction register with every box of checks. All personal and business checks from Checks In The Mail meet the Check Payment Systems Association’s (CPSA) safety guidelines. That means they use special paper, inks and design elements that are difficult to reproduce, even with modern printing capabilities. You can tell if your checks meet CPSA safety guidelines because there will be a padlock icon on each check. One important feature missing from this online check ordering service is a money-back guarantee. You will want to make sure that your information is correct before finalizing your order.
Pros
  • More than 300 design options, including popular characters from Marvel, Disney and Star Wars
  • State-of-the-art security features
  • Easy reorder process
Cons
  • No money-back guarantee
  • Popular themes are expensive
  • There is a fee to add your company logo

Why Trust Us?


We have been evaluating and researching financial and accounting services for more than 10 years. Our goal is to find the features and benefits of products offered by online check ordering services that are difficult to find by skimming the marketing material on a website.

We evaluate every step of the ordering process by using the service as a consumer would. We contact the support staff and ask questions as if we were actual customers to obtain information about, for example, security features and money-back guarantees. We also make sure you can get answers to questions that might arise after you place an order.

How We Evaluated


We identified four important feature categories for online check ordering services: customization options, check styles and add-ons, security, and help and support. We also compared the price for a standard, noncustomized box of single wallet checks from each service. However, pricing didn’t weigh into our final recommendations because the cost can vary widely depending on the options you choose.

All the products we evaluated have similar security features based on CPSA recommendations. But each online check ordering service has a wide selection of design options and business check options, so those features factored into our final recommendations. We also took into account helpful and fast customer support.

Important Features of Online Check Ordering Services                  


Customization Options
Better quality and a larger choice of design options are major reasons to order checks online instead of through your bank. If you’re looking for business checks, a company that allows you to add your logo might be your best bet. Others carry a wide range of stock logos. Not all companies offer popular images from movies and television for your personal checks. Others offer sports, nature and floral designs.

Check Styles and Add-Ons
The best online check ordering services give you access to business checks and personal checks that include methods of keeping track of the checks you’ve written and the money you spend. For personal checks, duplicate copies of deposit tickets and check registers are useful add-ons to consider. For business checks, if you like to hand-write checks, make sure there is a top stub or side stub to help you keep an accurate record. If you use accounting software like Quicken or QuickBooks, choose an online check ordering service that has check templates that will work with your software.

Security
The Check Payment Systems Association (CPSA) requires online check ordering services to use special paper and ink and unique designs to gain membership. Make sure you use an online check ordering service that is in compliance with that association. Checks that meet CPSA safety guidelines are marked with a padlock icon. Also, make sure the website you use to order checks is credible before you enter your account information.

Help and Support
The best online check ordering services have a toll-free phone number, email and live chat support. Most of the services in our comparison offer a money-back guarantee if there are problems with the printing or shipping process. If they don’t, make sure you enter the correct information before you finalize your order.


More Online Finance Guides:

id:884