Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links. Learn More


Gas Furnaces Reviews

reviews & comparisons

Gas Furnaces Review

Choosing Your Next Gas Furnace

The following is a compilation of information designed to assist in choosing the right furnace to meet your needs, along with information on what features, models and brands to consider. Additionally, there are details on what essential questions to ask your local HVAC installer when you are ready to have a unit installed in your home.

Gas furnaces are an essential element in your home's comfort level. They warm and transport heat throughout your home in cold seasons and push cooled air from a central air conditioning unit in the heat of summer. Unfortunately, it tends to be on the coldest night or hottest day of the year that your old gas furnace finally decides to give up the ghost, forcing you to call up your nearest heating, ventilating and air conditioning (HVAC) repairperson to install a new furnace immediately.

Purchasing a new furnace doesn't have to be a knee-jerk decision. We have extensively researched and compiled information about the major manufacturers of gas furnaces on this site as a guide to help you make an educated consumer choice when buying your newest furnace.

Furnaces have evolved over the past century from wood and coal stoves to oil or natural gas burning, and manufacturers have continued to improve designs to comply with government regulations and increase their efficiency over the past few decades. This means that your overall operating costs with a newer natural gas furnace should decrease while you enjoy consistent heating throughout the chilly seasons.

Gas Furnaces: Repair or Replace?

When your furnace experiences problems or just stops working altogether, you are faced with a troublesome decision: Do you try to repair the broken part, or invest in a completely new system? The first thing to consider when faced with this question is the age of your current gas furnace. If it is older than 10 years, chances are there have been advancements in efficiency or industry standards that you can benefit from if you replace your system.

Next, consult your warranty information. Many furnace manufacturers cover the heat exchange for 10 or more years, while some have lifetime coverage. Depending on the parts that need to be replaced, your furnace might be covered by a manufacturer's warranty. Additionally, many HVAC installers offer guarantees on their work, which can save you money if they are responsible for the problem.

Often, HVAC professionals recommend that you update or replace your existing gas furnace when you replace your central air unit. This is an excellent way to save money over time, as a high-efficiency furnace and a cooling system that are the same age and brand work together better than a mismatched-efficiency set of an older furnace and new AC unit. Unfortunately, this is not always a feasible option financially, as high-quality HVAC units can be priced in the thousands. If your current furnace's age is within five years of the new AC unit, it should work well with your new cooling unit.

Ultimately, it's up to you if you want to replace your furnace. To help you decide, consider the current efficiency of your home furnace, its age, and if you are willing to replace a part that may continue to fail in the years to come.

Gas Furnace Efficiency: It's Not Just About the Money

Size Matters
Unlike most major appliances that get better in functionality as they increase in price and size, furnaces need to be the right size for the layout of your home. This means that buying the biggest and most energy-efficient furnace on the market is typically not the best answer for your home.

Every home is different, whether in its layout, ventilation system or materials. A natural gas furnace that is too small will not be able to produce adequate heat in the winter or push enough cool air in the summer. Conversely, a system that is too large for your home will cost more to run and not efficiently maintain correct temperatures.

Energy Efficiency
If your gas furnace was installed in your home more than 15 years ago, you are pretty much guaranteed to be heating your home inefficiently. With a high-efficiency furnace, the amount of gas you need to warm your home decreases, as do the charges on your utility statements.

When selecting the best furnace, consider the device's annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) rating. This number is represented as a percentage and indicates how much heat a furnace can obtain from each cubic foot of gas. To clarify even more, for example, an AFUE rating of 96 percent means that up to 96 cents of every dollar is used to warm your home. The national standard for lowest allowable efficiency is 78 percent, and many modern units achieve upward of 98 percent.

A furnace with a high AFUE rating can save you a significant amount of money in heating and electricity bills. While a unit with more than 90 percent AFUE generally costs more than one with an 80 percent rating, you're likely to recoup any difference of cost over the furnace's lifespan.

Another way to increase the efficiency of your new furnace is to have a compatible programmable thermostat installed along with it. Many gas furnace manufacturers have their own lines of thermostats that can push and run your furnace to its peak efficiency levels. While this is an additional cost, an updated, compatible thermostat allows you greater control over your home's temperature and comfort levels.

What You Need to Know About Furnace Installation

A furnace is a major home-improvement investment, so any knowledge you can arm yourself with before deciding which new unit to purchase can save you time and money in the long run. Below are some key elements to forced air heating that you need to be aware of as you talk with your local HVAC professional.

Types of Gas Furnaces
Gas furnaces come in two varieties, single-stage and two-stage. Single-stage furnace blowers use a single-speed blower, which switches on and off until it reaches the desired temperature. These furnaces are usually older models, but you can still purchase one for your home that has an AFUE of 80 percent.

While these units can be a less expensive investment initially, the lower efficiency from switching on and off constantly ends up costing you more over time than a furnace with a variable-speed blower. That being said, if you have a smaller home, consult with your HVAC professional to see if a single-stage furnace would be a more viable option.

Two-stage gas furnaces operate similarly to single-stage ones, but when the temperature drops and the first stage is not producing enough heat, the second stage turns on to supplement your home's heating needs. This second stage allows your furnace to produce and use more heat with less effort and fuel. Another great side effect of a two-stage unit is that it generally runs much quieter than the single-stage models.

Variable-Speed Fans & Modulating Valves
Variable-speed fans are an additional option to increase the efficiency of the furnace. Rather than constantly turning off and on and blowing at an unalterable speed, the variable-speed blower has the ability to slow down the motor to provide constant heat with a longer, less stressful cycle. This speed control allows the furnace to use less gas and to operate much more quietly, a great bonus for heating large homes or awkward floor plans. Generally, two-stage furnaces are equipped with variable-speed fans, helping them run even more efficiently than they would with a standard, single-speed blower.

Some furnaces are equipped with a special modulating gas valve. This specialty component works in tandem with a variable-speed blower to provide consistent temperatures. This is much like driving an automobile on a freeway at a constant pace, rather than stopping and starting at every stoplight downtown. Modulating furnaces can reach an AFUE of up to 98 percent. While they cost more to purchase, these furnaces maximize your comfort levels and can greatly reduce your overall energy costs.

Other Furnaces

While gas furnaces are the standard for forced air heating across the nation, there are still some regions, such as the northeastern United States, that still use oil furnaces as their heaters. Oil furnaces burn a refined oil that is pumped in from a storage tank and burned as a mist. Once ignited, the oil furnace functions nearly identically to a gas furnace in gathering and distributing the generated heat.

If you are considering converting from an oil furnace to a gas furnace, be sure to consult with a licensed professional and get multiple quotes from your local HVAC installers. The overall cost of converting to a gas-line furnace varies, depending on availability, location and labor. Depending on your situation, it may be best to stay with an oil furnace rather than converting.

Measuring Your Home
When you call for a quote, your local HVAC professional should take some measurements of your home during their visit. This step is essential to selecting the best gas furnace for your home. If the HVAC professional does not come to your residence and perform a home measurement and analysis, this is a red flag that they do not have your best interest at heart and you should call another company to get a second opinion.

The way the installer measures your home is more than just calculating the square footage. Their measurements take into account your design of the interior of your home (which affects airflow), the local climate and construction materials of your home. These factors help the HVAC installer determine which size and type of furnace would be best. Then they can make a proper recommendation based on these facts.

Get It in Writing
When you get a quote, be sure to have any agreement or estimate put down in writing. This is not a petty thing to ask, and it helps ensure that any work that needs to be done is fully disclosed. Having your estimate in writing reduces the chances of being surprised by a different amount at the end of the job. A good HVAC professional is upfront with unit and labor costs, as well as knowledgeable about the gas furnace warranty they are installing.

In addition to getting a written estimate for furnace and material costs, be sure to get a start and finish date in writing. This will help you make plans accordingly and to know when you can expect to have heat again. Don't settle for weak answers in this regard. A quality professional HVAC installer will gladly set deadlines and promptly notify you of any unforeseen delays.

When an HVAC company replaces your home furnace, it is common practice to remove and replace older water heaters or ventilation piping, especially when they are not up to code. Having a new water heater or AC unit installed with your new furnace helps keep costs down, as they will most likely be of equivalent efficiency.

Your HVAC estimate should include any work that needs to be done besides a furnace replacement. Many newer, high-efficiency gas furnaces need to have additional plumbing worked into your existing furnace area. Be sure to ask if your new system will require any additional parts or systems beyond the main unit. Again, get it in writing.

Get a Second Opinion
Just because you called an HVAC company and it performed an estimate doesn't mean you are obligated to purchase from it. Natural gas furnaces generally last 10 to 15 years, so don't budge on getting the best furnace your budget allows. When you call for a quote, ask the HVAC company about its licensing. A suitable contractor needs to be licensed and certified to install your new system. If a contractor is not able or is reluctant to supply this information, don't use them, even if they are the lowest bid. Protect yourself and your home by hiring licensed professionals.

Make sure the HVAC contractor performs the home inspection mentioned above and that they explain all your options. If you feel pressured to buy without clearly understanding what you are purchasing, there is no guilt in telling a contractor "no thank you." The best HVAC contractors provide you with answers to your questions, clearly outline the work that is required and listen to your requests.

If you have the luxury of waiting a couple days before needing a new furnace, gathering a couple estimates can give you the opportunity to save money beyond the initial cost of the furnace and installation. By comparing and making a well-thought-out choice, you can be sure you will not only find the best deal on a heating system, but most likely find a reliable, quality installer as well.

Gas Furnaces: Major Brands Bring the Heat

When it comes to choosing from among the best gas furnaces, these are some of the brands that stand out above the rest. Their prominence in the HVAC market is due to manufacturing reliable, durable and energy-efficient units.

Carrier started as a pioneer in whole-building air conditioning in the early 1900s and has since branched out to manufacture reliable, high-performance gas furnaces as well. Carrier gas furnaces are grouped into three product lines. The Infinity series – which is where the best Carrier gas furnace, the Infinity 98 59MN7, can be found – offers two-stage and modulating furnaces for maximum efficiency.

The midrange-efficiency Performance line is home to the majority of Carrier's single- and two-stage furnaces, and it features furnaces such as the durable Performance 95 59TP5 that have efficiency ratings in the mid-to-high 90th percentile. Carrier also offers an affordable line of highly efficient single-stage furnaces, such as the Comfort 95 59C5, in its Comfort brand line. Discover more details about Carrier's best gas furnaces here.

Bryant also started operations in the early 1900s, specializing in gas-fired water heaters. Over the past century, Bryant continued to produce quality gas furnace lines, namely Evolution, Preferred and Legacy. Bryant began implementing high-efficiency features in its gas furnaces as early as 1981, leading the way for homeowners to save money on their forced air heating bills.

The best Bryant furnaces include the Evolution 987M, a modulating gas furnace that runs at up to 98.3 percent AFUE; the Preferred 926T, a two-stage with a variable-speed motor; and the Legacy 915S, a single-stage gas furnace that runs at an efficiency level of up to 95 percent. Bryant's lineup of furnaces provides you with a wide range of choices when you need to replace your current furnace. You'll find more detailed information about Bryant here.

Amana is a well-recognized name in the gas furnace industry, having provided homes with quality heat solutions for nearly a century. Currently, this manufacturer offers 16 gas furnaces for you to choose from, including standard and high-efficiency models. Amana's best furnace is the ACVM97, a modulating two-stage furnace that runs at up to 97 percent AFUE. Other choices for home heating include the AMEC96, another reliable two-stage gas furnace, and the AMS8, a single-stage model of 80 percent AFUE that is good for small homes or offices. Read more about Amana gas furnaces here.

Goodman is one of the largest manufacturers of residential heating furnaces in the nation. This HVAC manufacturer has a wide range of furnace models to choose from, including two furnaces that operate at above 97 percent AFUE. Goodman offers single-stage furnaces, such as the GMVC8, and energy-efficient models like the GCSS96, another single-stage gas furnace that operates at up to a remarkable 96 percent AFUE. The best furnace Goodman offers today is the modulating GMVM97, an Energy Star-compliant furnace that operates at up to 98 percent, giving you even heating while reducing your heating bill. Read more about Goodman gas furnaces and its model lineups here.

Coleman is best known for its outdoor equipment, but in the 1950s, it ventured into the home heating and cooling market. Today, Coleman has a smaller product lineup than the major brands, but it still offers quality units that are quite capable of efficiently heating your home during cold weather.

The noteworthy Coleman gas furnaces include the company's best furnace, the Echelon CP9C, a modulating, Energy Star-certified furnace that operates at up to 98 percent AFUE, and the LX TM9M, another fine modulating furnace that has a lifetime warranty on the heat exchanger. Coleman also has a nice selection of single-stage furnaces like the Comforteer TG9S, one of Coleman's top single-speed blower motor furnaces. Explore the options Coleman offers here.

While the Trane brand started off small in the cold of Wisconsin, it has grown over the past century to be recognized around the world as a member of the Ingersoll Rand family of companies. Trane provides homes around the world with efficient, reliable gas furnaces such as the XR95, an affordable single-stage gas furnace that operates with efficiencies up to 95 percent, and the XV95, an Energy Star-certified, two-stage unit that saves homeowners on their heating bills by efficiently regulating the amount of fuel and electricity needed to keep the temperature just right. The crown jewel of Trane gas furnaces is the XC95M, a modulating model that heats incredibly more efficiently than the others thanks to its special gas valve and variable blower speeds. Find out more about Trane and its available gas furnaces here.

American Standard
Though the American Standard gas furnace lineup is not as varied as those of the other best gas furnace manufacturers, it produces quality home heating and cooling options for homeowners who want affordability coupled with efficiency. American Standard has three brand lines, each with multiple models to choose from.

The Platinum 95 is the best of what American Standard has to offer. This modulating gas furnace can operate at up to 97.3 percent AFUE, giving you considerable savings on your heating bills. The Gold 80V offers quiet operation and heats your home evenly, while the American Standard 92 is one of the top single-stage furnaces it offers with its budget line. You can find out more about the options from American Standard here.

Rheem is a central air and heating manufacturer known for its wide selection of units and durability. This manufacturer builds more two-stage units than any other gas furnace company. Among these models are the noteworthy R96P from the Classic Plus Series and the quietly operating RGTM from the Classic Series. Rheem offers its best gas furnace as part of its Prestige Series: the R96V, an Energy Star-qualified unit that maintains the temperature of your home with incredible accuracy. Learn more about Rheem's wide range of gas furnaces here.

Dave Lennox built the world's first riveted-steel furnace in 1890, and because of his pioneering efforts, the Lennox company has continued to develop gas furnaces focused on efficiently heating your home. The Dave Lennox Signature Collection offers the finest furnaces Lennox has to offer homeowners, including the SLP98V, a modulating gas furnace with the highest achievable AFUE to date – up to 98.7 percent. Lennox's other quality furnaces, such as the EL196V and the ML195, are part of the Elite and Merit series and provide affordable heating solutions. Discover more information about Lennox gas furnaces and what makes its models worth installing.

York has built home comfort systems for over 135 years, and it offers affordable home heating solutions in its Affinity, LX and Latitude series of gas furnaces. This gas furnace manufacturer builds many efficient two-stage furnaces like the TM9V and several modulating gas furnaces, such as the efficient YP9C. York also carries single-stage furnaces, which are even more affordable than their two-stage cousins and ideal for small homes. Find out more about York gas furnaces here.

What Else Is Important When Selecting a Furnace?

Gas furnaces have other factors to consider beyond efficiency and installation. For example, furnace warranties vary between manufacturers. Yearly maintenance and reliability are also important to consider.

Warranty & Rebates
One of the most important elements of even the most high-efficiency furnace is its warranty. Replacing a furnace in its entirety is an incredibly expensive endeavor, and having to replace it every few years is problematic from a financial-planning standpoint. The ideal furnace carries two individual warranties: one for the heat exchange and another for all other parts. In addition, the best contractors provide a labor warranty to back up their work.

The heat exchange is the heart and soul of the furnace, as it influences how much heat a unit can get from burned gas. This warranty can extend up to and beyond 20 years, whereas the warranty for all parts may only be five to 10 years. Also, the brand of the furnace can influence its reliability. Lesser-known brands generally do not have quality parts or long warranties, and while they may be cheaper initially, repairs will cost you more in the long run.

Be sure to discuss the availability of manufacturer rebates or tax credits with your installer. This can be a great way to save money and offset the initial cost of a new furnace. Federal and local governments are encouraging homeowners to improve their dwellings' energy consumption, and you may be able to deduct the purchase of a new heating system on your taxes. Check with your contractor and tax agent to confirm any eligibility or programs currently available.

The lifespan of your furnace is influenced greatly by how well you, the owner, perform regular maintenance. This doesn't mean you have to know how to repair and rebuild a furnace unit, just that you should be able to perform basic maintenance tasks such as changing and correctly installing air filters, keeping the airflow path free of obstructions, and giving the main unit a visual inspection a couple times a year.

Air filters are one of the most important components of an efficient gas furnace. While older designs and cheaper furnace filters block large particles, they do not remove small particles such as pollen from the air that circulates through the system.

Fortunately, there are high-efficiency filters that you're better off using, especially if you have allergies, live in a dusty region or have pets that shed. While the high-efficiency filters cost more, the amount of particles they remove from the air helps you and your furnace breathe easier.

High-efficiency filters need to be changed approximately every three months, but you may need to replace them more often if you have multiple pets or someone who smokes in your home. While three months may seem quite often, if you use cheap, thin filters, you need to replace them at least every month, as they do not take as long to reach capacity.

Keep the area around your furnace free from obstructions, such as boxes, that can block air circulation. The burner inside your gas furnace needs to have enough oxygen to function properly, and a reduced air intake can be dangerous and cost you more money. Also, a couple times during the year, take a quick visual assessment to see if anything looks wrong, such as loose wires, bent panels or any ventilation pipes that need repair. Simple maintenance chores such as these can help keep your furnace in tip-top shape for years and your family toasty during the winter months.

Being left in the cold is definitely no fun, but fortunately, you won't be in the dark when you use our articles on gas furnaces to assist your educated decision. While you consider the different brands of furnaces as you read through this site, remember that it is just as important to find a local HVAC professional who will give you the best service possible by putting your needs before a sale. The best combination for your home and wallet is to choose the most efficient gas furnace that provides adequate coverage and to have it installed correctly by a qualified professional.