Best Truck Rental Services of 2018

Ryan Brown ·
Updated
We maintain strict editorial integrity when we evaluate products and services; however, Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links.

We researched the top national truck rental services and compared them on truck sizes, rental locations, insurance offerings and extra equipment offered. After our research, we determined that U-Haul is the best truck rental service overall because it offers the biggest size selection in trucks, and each of its trucks is capable of towing a car. U-Haul rents hand trucks and furniture pads at standard prices, and you can also purchase boxes and packing materials online or at a U-Haul rental location. This company has more than 20,000 locations in all 50 states and all but one Canadian province. 

Best Overall

U-Haul

U-Haul is the best-known truck rental company, and you can rent trucks or purchase packing and shipping supplies from over 20,000 locations in any state in the U.S. and most Canadian provinces.
View on U-Haul
Best Variety

Ryder

If you need to rent a refrigerated truck or a stake truck, Ryder offers these rentals. You can also rent vans, box trucks and straight trucks.
View on Ryder
Best Value

Budget Truck Rental

Budget Truck Rental works to match prices with its competitors and offers a wide range of coupons and discounts. This company also rents hand trucks and furniture pads to help with your move.
View on Budget
Best Overall
U-Haul is our top pick for truck rental services because it has the most truck sizes available. Its trucks come in five different sizes, in addition to cargo vans and pickups. This means you can match the size of your load to the size of the truck and not pay for extra space or have to make two trips.
One great benefit is that even the company’s smallest 10-foot truck can tow a car dolly or car carrier. In addition, all the trucks feature an overhead storage compartment called Mom’s Attic that can be used to keep fragile items up and out of the way. U-Haul also claims that its trucks have lower decks and wider, more stable loading ramps than other truck rental companies’. This company has the largest network of rental locations. You can rent trucks in all 50 states, as well as almost every Canadian province. U-Haul also sells boxes and packing materials, and you can rent hand trucks and furniture pads. If you reserve a truck, your reservation is guaranteed. This means you get a $50 refund if the company doesn’t give you the right truck at the right time. If you find a cheaper rate with a competitor, U-Haul may be able to match it.
Pros
  • Offers the most sizes of trucks
  • Have a Mom’s Attic for fragile items
  • Reservations are guaranteed
Cons
  • Doesn’t give you a discount for AAA membership
  • No live chat support on the website
  • Rates can change based on truck availability and demand
Visit SiteU-Haul
Read the full review
Best Variety
Ryder doesn’t offer a large selection of sizes for its truck rentals, but it does offer the most variety of the major companies we researched. You can rent moving vans and 16- or 26-foot trucks, and you can also rent refrigerated versions of those trucks.
If you’re moving landscaping materials or other weather-resistant objects, you can also rent one of Ryder’s stake trucks. It’s the only company we found that offers refrigerated truck rentals. This company offers a discount program called RedZone, where you get points for every dollar you spend on rentals – a perk if you rent trucks regularly. These points can be redeemed for appliances, TVs and many other products. Unfortunately, Ryder requires you return your rental truck to the same location where you picked it up. This means you can’t do cross-country, one-way moves with this company. It also doesn’t offer car towing or car carrying with any of its trucks, and you can’t use your own dolly or car carrier, either. Some locations rent hand trucks or furniture pads, but you need to verify that the one you’re using offers these services. Ryder charges you by calendar day, so you’re charged for two days’ use if you pick up a truck on one day and return it the next day. Other companies charge in 24-hour periods, so Ryder isn’t the best for value.
Pros
  • Carries refrigerated and stake trucks
  • Has a rewards program if you rent frequently
  • Businesses can rent tractors and trailers
Cons
  • Must return your truck to the original rental location
  • Can’t tow a car
  • Fewer rental locations than other companies
Visit SiteRyder
Read the full review
Best Value
Budget Truck Rental is our top pick for best value because it works to match competitor’s prices, and it offers promotions and coupons. According to our research, you get the best prices if you book as far in advance as you can and if you reserve a truck between Sunday and Thursday. Budget also offers discounts to military personnel, students and seniors.
This company only offers three sizes of trucks – 12-foot, 16-foot and 24-foot trucks – which is fewer sizes than our top pick, U-Haul. Also, only the 16- and 24-foot trucks can tow dollies or car carriers. You can rent hand trucks and furniture pads from this company to help your loading go smoothly. One downside is that Budget doesn’t guarantee its reservations. This means that if there’s a problem with scheduling, you may have to work with the managers to get a different truck than the one you reserved.
Pros
  • Will usually match a competitor’s price
  • Features protection plans that cover your move
  • Students, seniors, military personnel and others can get discounts
Cons
  • Only has three sizes of trucks
  • Drivers ages 18 to 23 need two forms of ID
  • Doesn’t offer a guarantee for its truck reservations
Visit SiteBudget
Read the full review

Why Trust Us? 

Top Ten Reviews has been researching and reviewing truck rental companies since 2010. We researched national and local truck companies to determine which ones to feature in our comparison. We chose to focus on national companies that offer local and one-way service.

How We Researched 

We first compared the physical dimensions of each truck offered by each company, using the listed measurements of height, width, length and deck height to determine the actual size. We also compared the stated fuel efficiency for each truck as well as each one’s towing capacity.

In addition, we looked at the number of rental locations each company has. Some companies don’t offer rentals in Alaska and Hawaii, and companies like Penske only offer truck rentals in a small number of Canadian provinces. Companies that offered rentals in more states and more provinces were rated higher.

Finally, we reviewed the terms and services for each company. Some don’t offer one-way moving, while others don’t offer reservation guarantees. We also compared the prices and features of the different insurance programs each company offers. You can purchase supplemental insurance and damage waivers to cover damage to the truck, your belongings and even yourself. 

How Much Does a Truck Rental Cost? 
The cost of renting a truck depends a lot on demand and seasonality. Because summer is the most popular moving time, the demand for trucks goes up and so does the price. College students often move home in the summer, so if you can schedule your move before, you’ll save money.

Rental truck costs generally include a set number of days of use and mileage. Truck availability and size will affect the cost of your rental.

According to the American Moving & Storage Association, in-state moves cost an average of $1,170 and out-of-state moves cost over $5,000. Many companies offer coupons that discount the rate, and you can also get bids from multiple companies and ask your preferred one if they can beat the lowest offer.

Extra Equipment
Truck rental companies often sell boxes and other packing materials. While gathering your own boxes is a good way to save money, purchasing them from a rental company usually means they are stronger and a uniform size, which is helpful for packing and loading.

You can also rent hand trucks and furniture pads to help you load and secure breakable furniture. Furniture pads usually cost $10 to $12 for a dozen, and hand trucks cost around $10 to rent. 

id:587