Skip to main content

Best Pool Heaters 2019: keep your pool at the perfect temperature all year round

Best Pool Heaters 2019 - Electric, Gas, Solar Heater Reviews

Here’s everything you need to know about how to choose the best gas, electric or solar heater for your pool.


Having a pool of your own is a dream come true, but the pool itself is only half the story. Without the right pool heater to keep the water at the optimum temperature, taking a dip won’t be the blissful experience it ought to be. However, a pool heater isn’t a ‘one size fits all’ item. There are several factors to take into consideration before you buy a pool heater, from the size of your pool to which type of fuel to go for – gas, electric or solar.

THE BEST POOL HEATERS

Pentair 460737 MasterTemp 400K BTU Propane Gas High Performance Eco-Friendly Heater

(Image credit: Amazon)

Pentair 460737 MasterTemp 400K BTU Propane Gas High Performance Eco-Friendly Heater

The best energy efficient propane gas pool heater

Dimensions: 36 x 25 x 30 inches | Fuel type: Propane Gas | Weighs: 128 pounds

Best-in-class energy efficiency
Low NOx emission
Digital display
Higher upfront cost than other heaters

This propane gas pool heater heats up quickly so you won’t have to wait around for hours before taking the plunge. It’s certified for low NOx emission and outperforms industry standards. It has a rotating digital display so it’s easy to view, and user-friendly indicator lights help make it easy to both operate this pool heater and monitor its performance. The the tough, rustproof exterior is designed to withstand all weathers, extending its longevity. The compact design and quiet operation mean you can swim in peace – it hardly makes a sound, so it won’t intrude on your poolside enjoyment.

 EcoSmart SMART POOL 18 Electric Tankless Pool Heater

(Image credit: Amazon)

EcoSmart SMART POOL 18 Electric Tankless Pool Heater

The best electric tankless water heater

Dimensions: 6 x 14 x 17 inches | Fuel type: Electric | Weighs: 24.5lb

Compact
Digital temperature control
Energy efficient
Complex to install

This differs from other electric pool heaters in so far as it’s an electric tankless heater. Instead of traditional pressure switch activation, the EcoSmart SMART POOL uses flow sensor technology, which increases its reliability and longevity, and also reduces the risk of elements burning out. The SMART POOL electric pool heater has a digital temperature display and dial that lets you set your preferred water temperature in 1-degree increments. It can be used as an alternative to a heat pump or as a booster. It’s compact and lightweight, and it’s energy-efficient – no matter what the ambient temperature.

Pentair 460737 MasterTemp 400K BTU Propane Gas High Performance Eco-Friendly Heater

(Image credit: Home Depot)

Hayward HeatPro 140,000 BTU Spa and Pool Heat Pump

The most economical electric heat pump

Dimensions: 32 x 43 x 40 inches | Fuel type: Electric | Weighs: 250 pounds

Quiet
Economical
Energy-efficient
Not as fast as a gas heater

Review: This HeatPro electric heat pump is ideal if you’re looking for an electric pool heater that will allow you to extend your pool season. It uses the outside air together with a titanium heat exchanger and profiled fan blade to generate heat for a fraction of the cost of gas pool heaters. The manufacturers say you could save up to 80% on your pool operating costs. As well as being energy efficient, it’s also easy to install and quiet to run, so you can enjoy your pool and back yard without the intrusion associated with a noisy pool heater.

Hayward H-Series 250,000 BTU Natural Gas Pool Heater Low NOx

(Image credit: Home Depot)

Hayward H-Series 250,000 BTU Natural Gas Pool Heater Low NOx

The best natural gas heater with low NOx emissions

Dimensions: 29.5 x 24 x 25 | Fuel type: Natural gas | Weighs: 165lb

Low NOx emissions 
Salt water and chemical corrosion resistance
Noisy

The Universal H-Series 250,000 BTU Natural Gas Heater is an energy efficient, high performance natural gas pool heater. The hydraulic design reduces circulation pump run time. It’s an environmentally friendly option for a gas heater as it produces low NOx emissions. This heater has a standard cupro nickel heat exchanger and offers ultimate installation flexibility on new or existing equipment pads. The forced draft system moves air through the combustion chamber at a precise flow rate, eliminating the outside weather variables that can affect the performance of a gas pool heater.

SunHeater S120U Universal Solar Pool Heater 2 by 20-Feet

(Image credit: Home Depot)

SunHeater S120U Universal Solar Pool Heater 2 by 20-Feet

The best solar pool heater

Dimensions: 120 x 27.5 x 16 inches | Fuel type: Solar | Weighs: 17.5lbs

Easy to install
Requires long hours of sunlight

If you’re looking for an eco-friendly, cost-effective way to heat your pool, we think this is it. The universal system is suitable for in-ground or above ground pools, and this solar pool heater could not be easier to install – it’s designed to be placed on your roof, ground or fence, and it works in conjunction with your existing pool pump. This solar pool heater captures heat from the sun’s rays and can raise the temperature of the water in your pool by 6-10 degrees Fahrenheit, adding weeks to your pool season.

Which type of pool heater should you choose?

Understanding how each type of pool heater works isn’t rocket science but a basic grasp of the logistics will help you choose the best heater for your pool. There are three main types of pool heaters: gas pool heaters, electric pool heaters (including heat pumps) and solar powered pool heaters. The difference between them is the power source they use, but this affects everything from the installation process to the running costs, as well as which climates they are appropriate for.

Gas pool heaters: 

A gas pool heater runs in a similar way to your home’s hot water heater – it burns natural gas or propane in a combustion chamber and transfers that heat to the water as it circulates through the heater. It has to be connected to a gas line through an underground gas pipe. This means that while the initial upfront cost may be lower than other types of pool heater, the installation costs are usually higher. And depending on the location of your nearest gas source, installation can even be prohibitively costly. 

In addition to the added installation cost, the ongoing running cost of a gas pool heater is higher. The price of gas, which fluctuates, will determine the exact ongoing cost of running a gas pool heater.

A gas pool heater tends to have a longer life span than other types of pool heater. This is because they’re so efficient and therefore in use for shorter periods of time, so they suffer less wear and tear. But when things do go wrong with a gas pool heater, repairs can be costly.

Gas pool heaters are more powerful than other types of pool heater, so they’re good for heating bigger pools that hold a large volume of water, and useful if you want to heat your pool in a hurry. They’re also ideal if you live in a cooler climate, or if you intend to heat the pool occasionally, and for short periods.

If you’re looking for an eco-friendly way to heat your pool, however, a gas pool heater is not the answer.

Solar Pool Heaters:

A solar pool heater is the most planet-friendly way to heat your pool. Unlike other types of pool heater, solar pool heaters use natural energy sources, making them the most economical option. A solar pool heater uses solar collectors to transfer the thermal energy of the sun to the water in the pool. You place the solar collectors near to the pool pump, so the heat is transferred to the water as it’s pumped into the pool.

Once you’ve installed a solar pool heater, you’ll have almost no maintenance costs and no monthly operating costs. Once the panels are in place, you can sit back and let the sun do its job.

A solar pool heater is very easy to install. They don’t need to be connected to any kind of energy outlet, so you won’t need to hire an installer. 

A solar pool heater works slowly compared to a gas pool heater, but once the pool reaches the desired temperature, it’s easy to keep it there – just remember to ensure that both your pool and the solar collectors get plenty of sunlight and aren’t located in a shaded area.

A solar pool heater is best suited to warmer climates that get plenty of sun. If you want to use the pool at night without experiencing colder water, you may need to purchase a diverter, so factor in the additional cost of this. 

Electric Pool Heaters:

As you might expect, electric pool heaters are the most popular type of pool heater, and arguably the most efficient. As well as performing consistently year-round, an electric pool heater is the fastest way to heat your pool. You’ll obviously have monthly costs with an electric pool heater – factor in that your electricity bill will go up – but you’ll spend less per month if you go for an energy-efficient electric pool heater, compared to one that’s cheaper to buy but has higher running costs.

Electric heat pumps
Electric heat pumps are more eco-friendly than gas pool heaters as they use the ambient temperature to heat the water. They don’t need to be connected to a gas line, so they're also easier to install than gas pool heaters. Electric heat pumps raise your pool’s temperature less quickly than gas pool heaters, but they can be kept running longer for less money, so they’re more cost-effective if you want to use your pool every day.

Climate

As we’ve explained, some models of pool heater rely on the ambient temperature or sunlight to heat the pool, so climate is a key factor in determining which pool heater is right for you. The climate also affects the energy requirements you need when calculating the power requirements for heating your pool.

What size?

Whether you want a gas, electric or solar pool heater, choosing the correct size heater for your pool is important. Gas and electric heaters are measured in BTU, or British thermal units. That’s the amount of energy it takes to raise one pound of water by one degree. The more you have to raise the temperature by, the more energy you need. It’s worth checking out one of the helpful calculators online to help you calculate the BTU you need in a pool heater. Consult a pool pro for more specific guidance.

Read more:

Best pressure pool cleaners

Best pool alarms

Best solar pool covers

ProductPriceOverall RatingPerformanceInterface & DurabilityHelp & SupportOutput (BTU)EfficiencyHeating TypeFuelAdditional SizesDigital Display and Control PanelSelf-DiagnosticsTroubleshooting IndicatorTempterature Lock SettingsWeather Resistant ExteriorWarrantyContact Options
Hayward HeatPro HP21104TView Deal4.5/59.3103110,000C.O.P. 4.0 - 5.7Heat PumpElectricity4Display Message1 YearPhone, Email, Post
Hayward Universal H200 FDN or FDPView Deal4.5/51083200,00083%Gas HeaterPropane or Natural Gas6Display Message-1 YearPhone, Email, Post
Pentair MasterTemp 460730View Deal4/5993.3200,00084%Gas HeaterPropane or Natural Gas4LED2 YearsPhone or Online Form
Raypak P-R207AView Deal4/58.3101.5199,50083%Gas HeaterNatural Gas3Display Message1 YearOnline Form
Jandy JXi 200N or 200PView Deal4/57.8103.8200,00083%Gas HeaterPropane or Natural Gas2Display Message1 YearPhone, Email, Live Chat or Online Form
Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm SR200View Deal4/58.393.3200,00084%Gas HeaterPropane or Natural Gas3LED2 YearsPhone or Online Form
Trane TR250NAView Deal4/57.885.8250,00083%Gas HeaterPropane or Natural Gas1Display Message-5 YearsPhone or Online Form
EcoSmart Smart POOL 27View Deal3/57.321018 kW/92,00099.8%TanklessElectricity1-None--LifetimePhone or Online Form
SmartPool SunHeater S425PView Deal2.5/56.325.8Varies100%SolarSolar1--None-5 YearsPhone or Online Form