Despite the growth of online cloud storage, the best external hard drives still remain a super-convenient and efficient way to save files, photos, music and video in a handy portable form factor. Whether you choose HDD or SSD external drives, both types can offer you the versatility that comes with having a ready extension to your other devices’ internal storage. But what is the difference between the two kinds of drive?
External HDDs are Hard Disc Drives which contain mechanical parts and spinning discs which story data magnetically. SSDs, or Solid State Drives, on the other hand, contain no moving parts and instead utilize flash memory to store data.
Most users agree that the best external hard drives are SSDs, which are a far more efficient and speedier solution than that offered by the older technology found in HDDs. SSSDs can transfer larger amounts of data faster. The lack of moving parts in SSDs also means that there is less that can go wrong with the devices. HDDs aren’t entirely redundant though, as they are generally much cheaper and often available in much larger storage capacities than SSDs.
Whichever external hard drive you choose, you’ll find you can easily plug one into most devices, such as the best home computers and the best laptops. External hard drives have become especially popular among gamers, for whom the best video game consoles always benefit from having more storage for games.
To help you pick the best external hard drive for you, we’ve assembled a list of the best options available, across HDDs and SSDs. We’ve considered a range of factors including storage, cost, value for money and reliability to help you choose the best drive for your needs.
1. WD Elements 2TB: Best external hard drive overall
Why you can trust Top Ten Reviews Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.
WD (Western Digital) is the leading name in portable hard drives, and the Elements is one of its most loved and trusted models. You can get a PC or Mac version, and it comes in all sizes from 500GB to 5TB, so there’s a size and version to suit every need. The Elements is compatible with PS4 and Xbox One consoles too, so can be used as a primary storage drive for game saves and installs. It’s a seriously versatile piece of hardware, and you can pick most sizes up for far less than $100, making it one of the best value HDDs out there.
What we especially like about the WD Elements is the design and durability of the HDD. It’s slim and easy to fit into the pocket of a rucksack or laptop bag, and it’ll even fit comfortably into smaller camera bags too. This makes it highly portable and - crucially - it’s unlikely to get damaged or corrupted along the way. It plugs into computers or laptops via a USB 3.0 connection, so is compatible with most devices. If you need USB-C that option is available in other WD hard drives.
The read and write speeds are standard for HDDs, and there’s no need to use any software to copy files across - you’re looking at a few seconds for 100MB of data. The WD MyPassport models - a slight upgrade - do offer auto back-up, but we’re not quite as sold on the design and toughness, even if they are very good HDDs all the same. WD Elements is available in a variety of colors too, to fit with your laptop or your lifestyle.
2. Samsung T7 1TB drive: Best external SSD
If you’re looking to get ultra-fast copy speeds, and a drive that’s super reliable, then an SSD (Solid State Drive) is the way to go. The Samsung T7 Touch (or T5, if you want to save a little money) is currently the best external SSD you can get… but it’s also very expensive. Here you’re paying close to $200 for a 1TB drive, which is about $150 more than the equivalent HDD. For most users, we’d absolutely recommend a regular HDD like the WD Elements, but an SSD like the T7 will suit certain groups that rely on SSD tech.
Because the read and write speeds are superior, an external SSD like the T7 is essential for anyone working with a lot of video editing, as it can shave hours off the time taken to copy large video files from one device to another. Similarly, if you’re looking for the most reliable form of storage, SSDs have no moving parts inside the case, so they’re less likely to malfunction or corrupt completely. If you’re going to be carrying your drive around a lot - for example, if you travel for work - then we’d suggest an SSD. There are rugged HDDs, which we will cover later, for outdoors use.
The T7 is the latest and fastest Samsung drive, and it boasts speeds up to nine times faster than regular HDDs. It has USC to C and A connectivity, and supports USB 3.2, so is fully compatible with all modern laptops, PCs, and smartphones. It has back-up encryption, and Samsung guarantees it against drops of up to 2m height, so it is fairly hardy too. The Touch part refers to the fingerprint scanner, which uses AES 256-bit encryption to protect your data - it's a neat innovation. We love this SSD, but its price is the main reason we didn’t place it in the top spot.
3. LaCie Rugged Mini 2TB: Toughest hard drive
The LaCie Rugged has a divisive design, but it’s a tough little HDD that you can 100% trust with your back-ups and files, no matter how you use it, and where you take it. The whole point is that this HDD is tough, and it’s designed to be bashed around inside rucksacks and luggage. More than that, it’s shock and drop resistant up to 1.2m, and can withstand pressure of up to 1000kg. While we’ve not tested this aspect ourselves, we have heard many stories - both online and from colleagues - that it can withstand being rolled over by smaller cars. Please, please don’t try this at home.
Copy and read speeds are equivalent to that of the WD Elements, and other standard HDDs, and it can be bought with both a USB 3.0 A connector and and a USB-C connector for more modern devices. You can buy devices from 1TB to 5TB, with an option for 500GB if you want to use a Thunderbolt connection, but we recommend 1TB or 2TB for purely practical purposes. If you’re buying one of these, you’re likely going to be knocking it around, and we wouldn’t recommend having more than 2TB of data stored on a single HDD if you are going to be that rough with it.
It’s thin, light, and perfectly suited for being packed tightly into luggage and pockets. A design classic, even if you’re not quite sold on that orange protective shell.
4. Seagate Expansion 6TB Desktop HDD: Best mass storage drive
If you need loads of storage, and you’re looking to keep your HDD in a home desk or office environment, the Seagate Expansion range is perfect. It’s a larger HDD, and it requires an external power source (you need to plug it in), but what you get is up to 10TB of storage space in a single device. That’s a lot.
Seagate is a top tier name in external storage, and its portable drives are some of the best you can get for video game consoles. In fact, even the desktop drives - like the 6TB and 10TB models - are fully compatible with PS4 and Xbox One. It also works with Macs and PCs, connecting via a USB 3.0 cable. You get standard HDD read and write speeds too, so there’s no slow in performance for it having a larger capacity.
We like the design too. While it isn’t as compact as smaller portable HDDs, it’s still modern-looking and not overly large, and it fits neatly into any office set-up. You can carry it with you, but we wouldn’t recommend longer or busy journeys, as it isn’t as resilient and most others.
5. Silicon Power PC60 960GB SSD: Best cheap SSD
If you're looking for fast SSD storage on a budget, then this is the drive for you. The Silicon Power PC60 is a neat, compact, quick solid state drive, that retails for a little over $100 right now. For 940GB of storage, this is exceptional value, and represents about $1 per GB, which is some of the cheapest rates out there.
The drive itself is small enough to fit in a shirt pocket, and comes with a ribbed design to help you keep a grip on it if your hands are sweaty. It's very small - about the size of a credit card wallet - and it plugs into your device via a USB-C 3.2 gen 2 connection. We tested it on a Windows PC, and managed to get speeds of between 360MB/s and 390MB/s read and write, which is what you'd expect from an SSD.
It's quiet and seems to be sturdy enough when knocked about with normal use (although we didn't attempt to throw or crush it). While we encountered no issues on a Mac test, we have noted that several users have complained of slowdown within a few weeks. If we get this fault, we will update this entry, but haven't done so far.
6. Buffalo MiniStation Extreme NFC - Best external hard drive for security
If you need a tough external hard drive to keep your data safe, look no further than the Buffalo MiniStation Extreme NFC. This ultra rugged external hard drive comes with “military spec” shock protection, an IPX3 water resistance and IPX5 dust resistance rating, as well as hardware encryption to keep your data safe from hackers, as well as the elements.
It’s not invulnerable so don’t throw it off a cliff into a river and expect it to keep working, but this tough little hard drive should keep your data safe from all but the most catastrophic of accidents. It’s ideal for keeping your data safe while traveling, and would make an ideal storage device for photos if you’re out hiking, taking pictures of the great outdoors.
On top of all these macho points, the Buffalo MiniStation Extreme NFC is smart as well as touch. It’s got NFC technology (hence the name) to keep your data secure - your data is locked unless you present the designated smart card to the NFC reader. You can also transfer data to and from the device quickly thanks to its USB 3.0 connection.
7. WD MyPassport 512GB SSD: Most reliable fast storage
You want speedy storage but don’t need much of it? The MyPassport SSD is perfect for this as it’s fast, reliable, and you can pick up the 512GB version for less than $100. Here, you’re only paying about twice the price for SSD speeds over regular HDD speeds, whereas you often pay triple for solid state drives of 1-2TB and upwards. We like the MyPassport because it’s small, well designed, and WD is a good name in portable storage, so it ticks a lot of boxes.
You get auto back-up with the WD MyPassport range, along with password protection and hardware encryption - fairly standard features, but it’s good to note they’re here. It has a range of connections, including USB-C and regular USB 3.0, and you can format for either PC or Mac. It’s fully compatible with games consoles too, although we wouldn’t recommend an external SSD for PS4 or Xbox One as you don’t gain much in terms of load time reductions.
The design is simple, the device itself is very neat and small, and it’s reliable and tough. You don’t get the same drop protection as the Samsung T7 drive, but it’s still a hardy SSD at a not-too-huge price.
8. Toshiba Canvio Basics 2TB: Great value, and perfect for games consoles
If you’re looking for a cheap way to extend storage on a video game console then the Toshiba Canvio line is perfect. You can get the 2TB version for less than $60 if you look hard enough, and it performs perfectly when used as an external HDD that simply stays plugged into a PS4 or Xbox One. With the 2TB version you triple the existing storage of your console (assuming you have a 1TB internal drive) so that means triple the games.
It works fine with PCs too, and comes with a USB 3.0 connection and some fine read and write speeds. The reason we recommend this one for games is because most leave their HDDs plugged into consoles, and never move them, so you don’t need to worry about how rugged the drive is, or how well you can carry it around. It’s simply designed and, to be fair, it can take a few knocks without any trouble. Crucially, Toshiba make good external HDDs and keep the costs low, so this is perfect if you want the most storage for your budget. Go any cheaper, with a brand you’ve never heard of, and you’ll likely run into problems with malfunctions and corruptions.
What is the difference between HDD and SSD?
You’ll see HDDs and SSDs referenced regularly, and they essentially do the same thing, so what’s the difference? A Hard Disk Drive (HDD) is an older style storage drive, which includes moving parts (a platter that spins at a certain speed when data is read or written). This not only limits the speeds at which it can copy or read files, but it also means that it is more liable to malfunctions or corruptions, as the spinning platter can be damaged or dislodged. More modern HDDs have ample protections to stop this happening - especially the better quality ones - but there is always a chance that the drive will fail the older and more beaten it gets. This technology is far cheaper, so HDDs are less expensive to buy.
A Solid State Drive is… exactly as it sounds. There are no moving parts here, so it’s far more difficult to damage. It also means that you get quicker read and write speeds - up to nine times faster than regular HDDs - although there are other factors that influence exactly how quickly your files transfer (such as the USB connection you use), so you may not quite get the same performance as manufacturers boast on the box. SSDs are, as a result, much more expensive - between two and three times that of regular HDDs. So think carefully about whether you need that extra performance and reliability, because you do pay for it. Increasingly, laptops and modern PCs are using internal SSDs, which are slightly cheaper, as either primary storage or drives to boot their operating system from.
How much can I fit on a drive?
As a rough estimate - as file sizes do vary - we've compiled the below table to give you an idea of how much storage you need.
|Size of HDD||Photos (12MP)||Songs||HD Video (Minutes)||Game Installs (50GB)|
|256GB||Up to 21,300||Up to 64,000||Up to 4,000||5|
|512GB||Up to 42,000||Up to 128,000||Up to 8,000||10|
|1TB||Up to 84,000||Up to 250,000||Up to 16,000||20|
|2TB||Up to 168,000||Up to 500,000||Up to 32,000||40|
|4TB||Up to 600,000||Up to 2m||Up to 128,000||160|
Do external hard drives work on Xbox/PlayStation?
Yes, external hard drives work on both Xbox and PlayStation games consoles… with a few caveats.
Both HDDs and SSDs will work on all models of Xbox One, along with the newer Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S consoles. However, if you want to make the most of your shiny games console, you’re going to want to use an SSD to store your games. This is because these newer games consoles have internal SSDs that they use to run games. Running games off a slower HDD will dramatically slow down the loading times.
On the PlayStation side of things, it’s a bit more complicated. Again, HDDs and SSDs will work on all PS4 variants, and again you’ll get better performance with an SSD. They’ll also kind of work on the PS5 too. What do we mean by kind of? You can store PS5 games on an external hard drive for the PS5, but you can’t play them from it.
What good is that, you might ask? Well, it’s still going to be quicker to transfer a game from your hard drive to your PS5’s internal memory than it would be to download the game from scratch, so you can use your external hard drive to shuffle games on and off of the console depending on what you’re playing at the moment. It’s also worth noting that you can still play PS4 games from external hard drives on the PS5. For more advice, check out PlayStation’s official guide to using USB extended storage on PS5.