Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links. Learn More

Best Picks

The Best Gas Lawn Mowers of 2017

We researched and tested 10 name-brand gas lawn mowers on similar lawns and evaluated each machine’s capabilities for a total of 220 hours.

Author by
Latest Update

These gas lawn mowers are powerful, but if you are looking for a greener, quieter way to mow your lawn, check out our reviews of electric lawn mowers.

The Best Gas Lawn Mowers of 2017
Our Ranking Gas Lawn Mowers Price
1 Honda HRX $619.99
2 Cub Cadet $399.99
3 Snapper $392.98
4 Honda HRR $439.00
5 Poulan Pro $378.52
6 Craftsman 37441 $329.99
7 Toro Personal Pace $419.00
8 Craftsman 37744 $379.99
9 Lawn-Boy $339.99
10 Troy-Bilt $269.00
Author by

Gas Lawn Mowers Review

How to Choose a Gas Lawn Mower

The top performers in our review are the Honda HRX217VKA, our Gold Award winner; the Cub Cadet SC 500 HW, our Silver Award winner; and the Snapper 12AVB2A2707, our Bronze Award winner. Here's more on choosing a mower to meet your needs, along with detail on how we arrived at our ranking of 10 gas lawn mowers.

Like most homeowners, you want your place to look well-cared-for and attractive. If your property includes a healthy lawn, you know the grass grows quickly and needs regular mowing so your yard doesn't look sloppy and run-down. To get a clean, even cut, you'll need to choose the best gas lawn mower to fit your lawn's needs.

Our lawn mower reviews and articles about gas lawn mowers and lawn care are full of helpful information. Finding the lawn mower that fits both your needs and budget doesn't have to be a daunting task. Use our research and hands-on testing to narrow down the selection and compare the best-rated gas lawn mowers with our side-by-side rankings.

Gas Lawn Mowers: Our Verdict & Recommendations

The best gas lawn mowers can make short work of grass cutting, giving you results you can be proud of. Through our evaluations, we found the top lawn mowers varied in their capabilities and design, but they can effectively cut the grass because they share features such as variable propulsion, powerful engines and even cutting.

The Honda HRX217VKA cuts smoothly and mulches well, and its variable speed system is comfortable and easy to control. While it is more expensive than most in our lineup, the quality of this gas mower is unmatched, and Honda engines have a reputation for longevity.

The Cub Cadet SC 500 HW offers superb maneuverability and a comfortable variable speed handle that adjusts to your walking speed. It also runs quieter than most gas lawn mowers, though not as quietly as an electric lawn mower.

The Snapper 12AVB2A2707 features a single lever to raise and lower the cutting deck. This is easy to clean and provides an exceptionally even cut for a mower under $400. It is a good choice for a midrange lawn mower.

If you are on a tight budget, less expensive lawn mowers like the Troy-Bilt TB200 or the Craftsman 37441 are quality choices. These machines, while they don't have as many features as our top-rated lawn mowers, can give your lawn a great cut for a much lower price. However, the Troy-Bilt and Craftsman mowers will most likely need to be replaced sooner than other machines in our product lineup.

Gas Lawn Mowers: What We Investigated, What We Found

We put lawn mowers through their paces by mowing grass and noting how well they compared to each other in a variety of ways. We examined the mowers in our lineup to see what features they offer to deal with various grass types and thicknesses. In addition, we researched the responsiveness of each mower, how well it performed with tall and short grass, and how evenly it can cut the lawn. We found that the best gas lawn mowers excelled in the following categories:

Lawn mowers all perform the same function, but their effectiveness depends on many factors, such as how well they cut and the width of their cutting paths. Our testing showed mowers with a cutting path of 21 inches or more reduced the time it took to mow grass.

Depending on the type of grass you have, as well as your personal preference, you should consider the cutting height of the lawn mower you select. Some grass varieties can handle being cut super short, while some look best at a longer or medium length. Be sure to check whether a mower will give you the optimal clearance you need. The mowers on our lineup can go as low as 3/4 of an inch and as high as 4 inches.

If you have a big yard, the size of the grass bag is also important, especially if you neglect to mow for a few weeks and need to bag the grass to get rid of it. You don't want to have to stop mowing every five minutes to empty a bag full of clippings. The gas lawn mowers with a two-bushel bag are able to hold more without impeding your mowing. How often you need to empty your mower bag is also proportional to the length of your grass, so be sure to mow often if you don't want to overburden your trash can.

Each mower is unique, and while they look similar, there are differences that can make it easier to mow your yard. The weight of each mower can affect its overall maneuverability. Lightweight or small lawn mowers are available for those who struggle with big and average-sized mowers. These light machines make mowing a large or hilly yard much easier, especially if you have to mow around flowerbeds and trees frequently.

Engine size can make a big difference in how well the mower cuts your grass, although you don't need to have the biggest engine to get the best results. Mowers that have at least a 150cc engine have plenty of power to cut the average yard. Handle height and cushioning are major contributing factors to how comfortable you can be when mowing. If you are over 6 feet tall, be sure to look for a mower with an adjustable handle that lets you mow without hunching, like the Craftsman 37744 lawn mower on our lineup. Handles that have some foam or rubber padding reduce hand and arm fatigue considerably compared to mowers that do not have any.

Self-Propelled Lawn Mowers

Mowing doesn't have to be a taxing exercise, especially if you choose a lawn mower that has built-in self-propulsion. Guiding a self-propelled lawn mower around the yard can be largely effortless, making it easier for you to mow the lawn, regardless of how strong you are. If you are looking for a walk-behind lawn mower that helps you get some exercise, our lineup of push mowers is worth a look.

The mowers on our lineup are equipped with a few different types of propulsion: front-, rear- and all-wheel drive. Front-wheel drive is best when your mower has plenty of weight in the front to keep the wheels on the ground. But unless you are mowing up an incline constantly, you may have to push more to keep the mower moving. Rear-wheel drive is the most common propulsion system and is effective, since the weight of the bag helps give traction to the wheels. All-wheel drive is great for mowing around obstacles, but it often makes the mower harder to pull back or move when the mower is off.

Self-propelled mowers generally have a single speed, but the best self-propelled lawn mowers have variable speed controls that adjust the speed to your walking speed. Some have thumb controls or, like the Cub Cadet SC 500 Z, a handle that adjusts with the pressure you place on it.

Best Mulching Lawn Mowers

Mulching is the process of the lawn mower blade chopping up grass clippings into fine pieces as you pass over them while mowing. This reduces the waste to be bagged or raked, and because the clippings are cut into such small, fine pieces, they dry and decompose quickly, providing nutrients to the roots of the grass. Many states and communities have restrictions on green waste disposal, with possible fines for including grass clippings with your regular trash pickup. A great way to avoid fines and give your lawn a natural fertilizer is to use your gas lawn mower in mulching mode.

Mulching is most effective with a maintained lawn and dry grass. Trying to mow and mulch with wet grass results in clumps and a frequently blocked blade. While all the mowers on our lineup can mulch, some are more effective than others. The Honda models in our lineup have exceptional mulching capabilities thanks to their specialty blades, and the Toro lawn mower does a fine job as well. Push lawn mowers such as these can help keep your lawn looking nice without you having to fill your garbage can with messy clippings or wearing yourself out raking your yard.

Overall, we discovered that gas lawn mowers are an essential lawn tool for any homeowner who wants to keep a truly appealing lawn. The gas lawn mowers simplify the chore of trimming your grass with convenient features like self-propulsion. If you are careful to select a mower that not only suits the type of grass and terrain in your yard, but also works correctly with your personal physical needs, mowing the law should be a simple, straightforward task and your place will be the envy of the neighborhood.

Contributing Reviewer: Linda Thomson