by

Pros / You can order one card at a time to compare cards or confirm you like a card before ordering in bulk.

Cons / There is only one paper option.

 Verdict / Postable is a good service if you want to keep it simple. There is a selection of attractive template designs for cars and postcards, and the sample card we created scored high points among our testers.

Postable is a good photo card service with plenty of template options for all the major holidays and events of all kinds. Many of the designs on the website are simple but nicely conceived and formatted, without a lot of the busy or dated elements that we saw on some sites. While there is only one paper option for cards, it is a good one, and you can go the postcard route if you want to save money. We ordered a card that tested well among our panelists. Despite the lack of options in some areas, this is a solid photo card service. 

Postable has an attractive, functional website that is relatively easy to navigate. From the main page, you can do a search for Christmas photo cards and it will take you directly to its selection of templates. You can also click on the card prompt on the main page and scroll through the various template categories. However, there are no filters for photo orientation or size to narrow your search to landscape or portrait designs. You also can’t preview photos in a variety of templates at the same time.

For cards, there is only one paper option: a sturdy recycled cardstock. This will work well enough for most people, but it doesn’t allow you to opt for cheaper materials like photo paper. You do save on the price of each card when you buy in bulk, but it’s not the cheapest service we reviewed. You can choose to create a postcard for your holiday greeting, invitation or announcement, which is half the price of a card. You can choose from a variety of designs on the back of the card, but the front of the postcard only has space for an address.

You can order cards individually to confirm if you like the design before ordering more. Individual cards cost more per card than buying in bulk, and you have to pay for individual postage, so most people won’t want to do this in excess, but it’s nice to have the option, for instance, to compare the layout of two different cards to decide which one you like better.

We tested this service by creating a card online and having it shipped to us to be assessed by a panel of testers who each have experience in design. It took the card five business days to arrive in the mail, which is about average when compared with other photo card services. The test card had a simple design that emphasized the photo collage by spreading it out across the card with a simple Christmas wish in the center.

The testers liked the thickness and heft of the cardstock paper, but one felt the textured matte surface gave the photos a fuzzy look. For the most part, however, the testers really liked the layout, look and feel of this card. A couple testers said they would order a card like this for themselves. The overall card and design quality scores our testers gave were 91 and 95 percent respectively.

Customer support options, if you have questions or need help, are limited to telephone, email and an FAQs section on the website. Many services offer a conditional money-back guarantee if you aren’t satisfied with your cards, but this service is not one of them.

Postable Visit Site
  • Card Quality
  • Design Quality
  • Holiday Selection
  • Cards for $30
  1. Score for appearance and quality of cards and envelopes.
    Higher is Better.
  2. 9  Postable
    91.0 %
  3. 100.0 %
  4. 96.0 %
  5. 3  Minted
    86.0 %
  6. Category Average
    89.4 %

Summary

Postable thrives on simplicity, both in its photo card designs and its options. There is only one option for paper: a high quality recycled cardstock that it isn’t exactly cheap. If you want to save money, you can create a similar design on a postcard for half the price. The sample card we ordered through Postable tested well among our panel of judges and was one of the more attractive designs we saw.

Postable Visit Site

Specifications and Benchmarks

Convenience

Delivery Speed
Average
Cards for $30
12
Minimum Order Quantity
1
Photo Quantity Filter
Photo Orientation Filter
Size Filter
Price Range Filter
Multi-layout Preview

Quality & Services

Card Quality
91%
Design Quality
95%
Paper Options
1
Print Quality Warning
Address List
Foil Finishes
Border Variety
Large Quantity Discount
Custom Design Service
Multiple Envelope Colors
Lined Envelopes
Postage Stamps
Mailing Service
Pre-order Envelopes
Keyword Search
Embossing
Paper Proofs

Template Selection

Holiday Selection
90%
Valentines Day
Chinese New Year
Diwali
Halloween
Thanksgiving
Hanukkah
Christmas/Winter Holiday
Pet Holiday
Ornaments
Kwanzaa
New Year

Help & Support

Telephone & Email
Chat
Money-back Guarantee
FAQs