We've reviewed wireless security cameras since 2012 and spent more than 105 hours in the last year testing quality in four categories: video, audio, ease of use and connection. When our testing concluded, the Nest Cam Indoor earned our highest score as the best security camera overall. It has excellent video quality, works with countless smart home devices and has exceptional customer support.
Nest Cam Indoor
Belkin NetCam HD+
Flir FX
Product
|
||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Price
|
||||||||
Overall Rating
|
9.3
|
9.2
|
8.9
|
8.9
|
8.8
|
8.7
|
8.6
|
8.3
|
Video & Audio
|
9.3
|
9.9
|
9.3
|
9.4
|
9
|
9.4
|
8.4
|
7.8
|
Convenience & Operation
|
9.1
|
7.8
|
8.8
|
7.9
|
8.4
|
7.3
|
8.5
|
9.3
|
Help & Support
|
10
|
8.6
|
8
|
8.6
|
8.6
|
8.6
|
9.4
|
8.6
|
Storage Type
|
Cloud
|
Cloud/microSD
|
microSD
|
microSD
|
Cloud
|
Cloud/microSD
|
Cloud
|
Cloud
|
Monthly Pricing
|
$10
|
$9.99
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
$9.99
|
$4.99
|
$5.99
|
$3.99
|
Warranty
|
2 Years
|
1 Year
|
1 Year
|
1 Year
|
1 Year
|
1 Year
|
2 Years
|
1 Year
|
Customer Support
|
All
|
All
|
Phone, Email
|
All
|
All
|
All
|
Phone, Chat
|
All
|
Scheduled Recording
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
||||
Ease of Use
|
86%
|
75%
|
93%
|
86%
|
75%
|
69%
|
86%
|
96%
|
Location Detection
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
||
Video Quality – Night
|
78%
|
89%
|
78%
|
89%
|
67%
|
67%
|
100%
|
56%
|
Still Images
|
||||||||
Video Quality – Day
|
97%
|
100%
|
100%
|
97%
|
100%
|
97%
|
84%
|
81%
|
Standout Feature
|
Excellent Low-Light Video
|
Best Overall Video
|
Widest Field of View
|
Excellent Nighttime Video
|
Excellent Daytime Video
|
Best Audio
|
Best Nighttime Video
|
Best Mobile App
|
Supports 5 GHz Wi-Fi
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
||||
Home Automation Platform
|
Nest
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
SmartThings
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
WeMo
|
IFTTT
|
Connection Quality
|
90%
|
90%
|
80%
|
70%
|
90%
|
80%
|
90%
|
80%
|
Two-Way Audio
|
||||||||
Sound Detection
|
N/A
|
|||||||
Audio Quality
|
80%
|
90%
|
70%
|
70%
|
80%
|
100%
|
50%
|
80%
|
Field of View
|
130º
|
160º
|
180º
|
128º
|
130º
|
120º
|
95º
|
120º
|
Resolution
|
1080p
|
1080p
|
1080p
|
1080p
|
1080p
|
1080p
|
720p
|
720p
|
Digital Zoom
|
8x
|
5x
|
8x
|
10x
|
8x
|
8x
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
Night Vision Range
|
20 ft
|
20 ft
|
16 ft
|
62 ft
|
25 ft
|
24 ft
|
15 ft
|
23 ft
|
Nest Cam Indoor
-
Excellent low-light daytime video
-
Easy to set up and use
-
Strong smart-home compatibility
-
Highest cloud monitoring fees
-
Average nighttime video quality
-
No scheduled recording options
Belkin NetCam HD+
-
Best nighttime video quality in our tests
-
Very affordable
-
Smart home compatibility
-
Average daytime video quality
-
Poor audio quality
-
No scheduled recording options
Flir FX
-
Best daytime video quality in our tests
-
Excellent nighttime video quality
-
Excellent audio quality
-
Only has one-year warranty
-
No smart home compatibility
-
Must charge prior to setup
Why Trust Us?
We started reviewing security cameras in 2012 and have devoted hundreds of hours to research and testing since then. Our research focuses on which types of cameras are best for beginners. We chose to focus on indoor cameras, since inside is the best place to put your first one. Each camera we tested connects via a mobile app and Wi-Fi. We specifically focused on fixed cameras with a wide field of view, at least 80 degrees, so they can monitor an entire room from a corner.
We chose cameras with similar pricing between $70 and $200, though cost doesn't currently play a role in our scores. In terms of features and quality, this is a step above budget security cameras. The cameras have 720p HD video resolution or greater and night vision, which are essential attributes in modern security cameras.
We also researched ways to test the cameras in real-world scenarios, rather than relying on confusing technical benchmarks. We hold each camera to the same standards and test them in similar conditions. We use the data from our tests to find the different strengths of each camera and to inform our recommendations.
How We Tested
Video
For daylight video tests, we wrote on a poster and placed it 16 feet away to compare each camera's indoor video quality. We used two lighting settings: natural light with the lights on and natural light on its own. We found the video was often better with the lights on than with natural light alone. The Flir FX and Foscam C2 had the best results with lights on. In low-light conditions, the Nest Cam Indoor and the D-Link DCS-2630L were better.
Aside from overall daytime video quality, we also looked at each camera's picture clarity. Predictably, higher-resolution cameras yielded the best results in this test, with 1080p cameras showing greater detail than 720p models. The Flir FX, D-Link DCS-2630L and Netgear Arlo Q had the clearest video among 1080p cameras, while the Belkin NetCam HD+ was the best among 720p cameras.
We concluded testing by evaluating how well each camera handled motion. The D-Link DCS-2630L and the Netgear Arlo Q recorded movement well, while the other cameras had at least some lag and image distortion. Internet speed can affect lag, so motion is often worse on live video feeds, while recordings have fewer problems than live streams.
Nighttime videos use infrared light instead of visible light, so they don't match the color or detail of daytime videos. Therefore, we assessed the brightness of the nighttime picture instead, with brighter video producing more detail. The top nighttime security camera was the Belkin NetCam HD+, which illuminated our room better than other cameras.
Audio
Our audio tests took a simple approach:we listened for loud, understandable audio. Some cameras were loud but the audio was distorted, while others cameras lacked distortion but were too quiet, making it harder to hear activity. The Foscam C2 was the only camera we tested with no audio distortion. Built-in speakers on each camera we tested, except the Y-cam Indoor HDS, let you use the mobile app to talk to anyone near the camera.
Ease of Use
To test ease of use, we tracked setup issues and whether we had to contact customer support. Cameras that quickly connected to Wi-Fi and had simple setup steps scored well.The Samsung SmartCam HD Pro had the easiest installation. Next, we looked for useful smartphone apps that show recordings, live streaming and basic settings on the first screen you see. The apps from Oco and D-Link were the easiest to use.
Connection
Our final test evaluated the Wi-Fi connection. To do this, we connected each camera to our Wi-Fi network along with a video streaming service and a smartphone. If a camera had connection problems, while the other devices and the router still worked, we deducted points accordingly.
Other Things to Consider When Buying a Security Camera
Video Storage: Local or Cloud?
There are two kinds of storage, local and cloud, neither of which had any effect on our scoring because it boils down to personal preference. The cameras with local storage in our review use micro-SD memory cards to save video footage. This lets you access your video without subscription fees, though you might need extra memory cards or to write over older footage if you plan to keep your camera recording at all times.
Cloud storage holds more video than local storage, but there are often subscription fees. You typically don't need a subscription to view a live feed. However, if you can't reach the company's video servers, you can't access the recordings. On the other hand, cloud storage is easier to use than local and is more likely to record everything the camera sees. The Y-cam Indoor HDS is the only camera in our review with free cloud storage.
Field of View
If you choose a camera with a very wide field of view, at least 160 degrees, you can expect to see every part of the room in front of the camera. The widest field of view in our review is the D-Link DCS-2630L at 180 degrees. A wide field of view, which the majority of the cameras we reviewed have, is anything larger than 80 degrees, and it works best if you mount the camera high in a corner that overlooks the room.
Digital Zoom
Digital zoom allows you to select part of the video and enlarge it. While this helps you get a closer look at something, the quality of a digitally enlarged video won't match that of the original. The Samsung SmartCam HD Pro has the highest digital zoom in the review at 10x.
Smart Home Platform
Before you buy, check if any home automation or DIY home security systems work with the camera. These systems can use Wi-Fi security cameras to control smart locks, thermostats and other devices in your smart home. Likewise, these devices can tell the camera to record or not, based on your personal preferences. The biggest appeal with these systems comes from using a single app to control all of the smart home devices.
Warranty
It is common among consumer electronics to find a one-year warranty. Longer warranties give you more time to replace the unit if it stops working due to a manufacturing defect. The longest warranty we saw, found on both the Nest Cam and the Belkin NetCam HD+, is two years.
More Home Security Guides:
id:972