Best Toasters of 2018

Rebecca Spear ·
Digital Photo Editing & Small Appliance Writer
Updated
We maintain strict editorial integrity when we evaluate products and services; however, Top Ten Reviews may earn money when you click on links.

After toasting countless bagels and slices of bread, we’ve determined the Breville Smart Toaster BTA840XL is the best overall toaster for most people. In our tests, this model toasted evenly and consistently, and it ably toasted frozen bread and bagels as well. It has wide and long toast slots to fit various sizes of bread, as well as multiple features that aren’t found on many other toasters.

Best Overall
Breville Smart Toaster BTA840XL
This device made evenly toasted bread in our tests on a consistent basis. Many toasters get hotter and will burn the second or third batch of toast, but the Breville Smart Toaster kept the heat consistent.
View on Amazon
Best Value
Dash Clear View DVTS501RD
This toaster retained consistent heat after several uses and toasted bread evenly during our testing. It is one of the least expensive toasters we reviewed, making it a great value choice.
View on Amazon
Best for Bagels
Smeg 2 Slice TSF01PGUS
This retro-looking appliance toasts bagels wonderfully and looks great on your kitchen counter. But it struggles with consistent heat and burns bread even at a medium setting, so we recommend keeping it at a low temperature.
View on Amazon
Product
Price
Overall Rating
Performance
Design
Features
Safety
Help & Support
Depth (inches)
Width (inches)
Weight (pounds)
Height (inches)
Online User Manual
Phone/Email
Warranty
Automatic Shut-Off
Exterior Temperature (Fahrenheit)
Stop/Eject
High Lift
Slot Length (inches)
Hideaway Cord
Cord Length (feet)
Slot Width (inches)
Lowering System
Color Options
Removable Crumb Tray
Slots
Slot Depth (inches)
Number of Shade Settings
Evenness Score
Reheat
Time to Done (minutes:seconds)
Ease of Use Score
Bagel Score
Frozen Score
Consistency Score
Adjustable Settings
Progress Indicator
Audio Alert
Digital Display
Illuminated Buttons
Dual Control
Lift and Look
$172.00 Amazon
9.8 10 10 9.8 9.3 8
13.2
13.2
9.5
9.2
1 Year
110.7
5.5
3.1
1.6
Auto
1
Front
2 or 4
5.0
5
100%
2:18
92%
100%
98%
99%
Light
-
$85.99 Amazon
9.5 10 8.8 10 8.8 8
7.5
12.2
5.3
7.5
1 Year
-
92.2
5.5
2.5
1.5
Manual
1
Front
4
4.5
7
98%
2:10
100%
98%
100%
100%
-
Timer
-
$68.90 Amazon
9.4 9 9.5 9.8 10 10
11
10.2
5.5
7.3
3 Years
88.8
5.5
2.6
1.5
Auto
1
Back
2 or 4
5.0
7
80%
2:04
93%
98%
80%
93%
-
Light
-
$79.95 Amazon
9.2 9.3 10 9.5 7.8 8
15.5
8.1
6.1
8.2
1 Year
-
129.3
9.8
3.0
1.5
Auto
1
Front
2
5.0
5
83%
2:34
87%
100%
93%
99%
Light
-
-
$130.00 Amazon
8.8 9.5 8.5 8.3 7.3 10
12.5
11.4
6.1
8
3 Years
81.2
-
5.3
2.4
1.4
Manual
5
Back
2 or 4
5.0
6
93%
1:27
86%
95%
88%
89%
-
-
-
-
$33.29 Amazon
8.5 9.3 8.8 7.8 6.8 8
8
18
4.4
5.8
1 Year
92.6
-
10.5
3.4
1.5
Manual
4
Back
1
4.0
7
95%
2:15
84%
80%
93%
99%
-
-
-
-
-
$40.39 Amazon
8.1 8.5 8.8 8.3 5.8 9
13.5
13.3
5.3
8.6
2 Years
-
95.7
-
5.8
3.2
1.5
Manual
1
Front
2 or 4
4.5
6
73%
2:44
89%
95%
78%
86%
-
-
-
-
$144.95 Amazon
8.1 9 8.8 7.8 4.8 8
15.5
8.5
7.1
8
1 Year
-
127.9
-
6.0
2.9
1.5
Manual
7
Back
2 or 4
4.3
6
85%
1:24
72%
100%
85%
89%
-
-
-
-
-
$149.00 Amazon
7.6 8 8.8 6.8 5.8 8
4.5
16
7.5
4.5
1 Year
-
91.3
-
5.5
5.5
1.5
Manual
1
Front
2 or 4
4.0
6
78%
-
1:57
85%
63%
68%
86%
-
-
-
-
-
Best Overall
This is hands-down the best toaster we reviewed. To start, no device is better at toasting bread evenly. In our tests, every slice of bread came out nicely browned on both sides, with minimal visible bar marks and no burning. It also did a great job with defrosting and toasting frozen bread.
In one round of testing, we toasted multiple slices of bread back to back to see if the toaster would get hotter over time and begin to burn bread. This toaster maintained consistent heat and repeatedly made good toast. It yielded similar results toasting frozen bread. And in our bagel test, it continued to excel. The toaster has a bagel feature that toasts just one side of the bagel so that it’s crunchy on the inner side and soft on the outside. This toaster comes with some unique features, too. The Lift and Look feature lets you check on the toast midcycle. When you press a single button, the bread pops up for a few seconds and then lowers back into the toaster to finish. The A Bit More function works in tandem with the Lift and Look feature: If you think the bread needs a bit more time, this feature adds another 30 seconds to the toasting time without changing the main timing dial.
Pros
  • Makes great toast
  • Stays at the same temperature after several uses
  • Has a bagel setting to toast one side of a bagel
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Relatively heavy
  • No digital display
$143.19Amazon
Read the full review
Best Value
The Dash Clear View toaster performed well in our tests, producing toast that was evenly browned on both sides without any burn marks. The device also did an exceptional job toasting frozen bread and bagels.
The glass door on the front of the toaster allows you to watch the browning process. Admittedly, this is a bit of a novelty design. As soon as you become familiar with your toaster, you’ll likely keep the same settings and won’t need to use the glass window all that often. But it’s nice while you learn the sweet-spot settings. There are a few tradeoffs for this best-value toaster. For one, the crumb tray is awkward to access. Longer than it is wide, the tray is accessed from the side of the toaster. If the toaster sits next to a wall or other objects, you’ll have to move it to fully remove the tray. It is also a bit of a pain to pull out. The toaster has just one slot, even though it is long enough to fit two slices of bread. If you have two pieces of longer bread – such as sourdough – you might not be able to fit more than one slice in the slot at a time.
Pros
  • Glass window lets you watch bread as it toasts
  • Inexpensive
  • Good heat consistency
Cons
  • Toaster has only one slot
  • Two large slices of bread might not fit into the toaster
  • Crumb tray is difficult to access
$34.11Amazon
Read the full review
Best for Bagels
This toaster could get an award for the best-looking, but we also enjoyed the way the Smeg warms bagels. It looks great on the countertop and comes in a handful of colors, and it makes great toasted bagels. However, it didn’t test well when it came to toasting bread.
This device simply runs hot. After repeated use, it gets hotter and hotter. When you make multiple slices of toast back to back, the later ones become burned even though the settings haven’t changed. But on a low setting, this toaster makes great toasted bagels. In fact, it was better than all others in this category. Not only does the inside of the toaster get increasingly hot after multiple uses – so does the exterior. The external temperature reached 127.9 degrees Fahrenheit and was the second hottest toaster we tested. This is a bit of a safety concern when you’re reaching in to grab your toast. That said, if you eat more bagels than toast, you’ll want to consider this great-looking toaster.
Pros
  • Good-looking retro design
  • Great for making bagels
  • Available in several colors
Cons
  • Gets hot after repeated use
  • Medium settings burn bread
  • Expensive
$149.95Amazon
Read the full review
Longest Cord
The Waring WCT 708 is a four-slot toaster with a 5.5-foot cord, making it the easiest toaster to place on your counter.
This toaster is also one of the most expensive models we tested, and it has the least amount of features – a disappointing fact when cheaper models like the Dash Clear View outperformed it for less money. We really did like the fact that we could plug this toaster in and put if nearly anywhere on our testing counter. This is a great feature for cluttered counters with power outlets in odd places or kitchen islands. Fortunately, the cord is retractable, so it stays out of the way for storage.
Pros
  • This toaster has an extra-long power cord.
Cons
  • There’s no setting for toasting just one side of a bagel.
$186.99Amazon
Read the full review
Best Digital Toaster
The Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast is a digital 4-slice toaster that has the longest warranty of all the toasters we tested – three years.
It also has push-button digital controls, including an automatic lift so you can check on the progress of your toast. For a full featured digital toaster, the Touch to Toast toaster is somewhat affordable, although it is much more than a $20 budget model. Fortunately, this toaster is excellent with bagels, scoring a 98 percent on our tests. The special bagel setting works well, and the toaster consistently produces the same quality, even after continual, repeated testing by our reviewers. The Cuisinart is also one of the safest toasters available as it has an automatic shutoff feature. If the toaster gets jammed, it will turn itself off to prevent overheating and possible fire hazard.
Pros
  • The Touch to Toast is affordable for an automatic, 4-slice digital toaster.
Cons
  • In our tests, the outer slots unevenly toasted the bread on both sides.
$79.99Amazon
Read the full review

Why Trust Us 

We have been researching and testing toasters for seven years. We have watched (and continued to update our testing methods) as toasters have evolved from a relatively simple appliance that you never think about to a versatile one with many settings and features to help create perfect toast and bagels. We’ve toasted many bagels, dry bread slices and frozen bread during our testing to make sure we can tell you exactly how each one performs. 

How We Tested 

To evaluate each toaster’s performance, we conducted four tests:

Evenness
The evenness test was the most critical and heavily weighted test we performed. We set the toaster on the medium heat level and toasted a slice of white bread. We checked for evenness on both sides of the bread, as well as for burn marks.

Consistency
Some toasters get hotter after repeated use. The toaster will toast the first batch of bread evenly, but the second and third batches progressively become more burnt. We toasted several slices back-to-back on a medium setting and in the same slot to determine heat consistency. Toasters that maintained evenly toasted bread after several uses received high scores.

Frozen
If you freeze bread for longer storage, you’ll want a  toaster that can cook frozen bread. We tested how well the appliance toasted frozen bread by setting the toaster on the medium level. If the toaster offered a defrost setting, we used it for the tests. We looked for evenness and consistency in the toast. We noticed that toasters with a defrost setting did much better than ones without it.

Bagel
Finally, we checked to see how well each model toasted bagels on a medium setting. If the toaster had a bagel setting – to toast just one side of the bagel – we used that. 

How Much Do Toasters Cost?

Toasters come in a wide variety of styles but spending more is not always a guarantee of better toast. In our tests we found that some of our cheapest toasters made better toast than some high-end models. Toasters can range in price from less than $20 to over $150 and can feature digital or manual controls. Generally speaking, toasters with more cooking slots cost more – depending on the quality of the toaster. Our advice is to purchase a toaster that has enough slots to fit your favorite breads or bagels and fits your budget.

Other Important Considerations

Cleaning & Reliability
If you are looking for a toaster that won’t leave a mess, find one that has an easy-to-remove crumb tray. A crumb tray that can be removed from the front is the most convenient and easiest to clean and replace. When we spoke with Alexus, an appliance associate at Best Buy, she told us that the number one reason toasters were returned – surprisingly enough – was because the crumb trays were difficult to remove. “You get what you pay for. The cheaper ones won’t cost as much, but they might be plastic or require a manual to know how to remove [the crumb tray].” She went on to say that the more expensive devices, while they do cost more, are typically better designed and easier to use.

We contacted multiple restaurant locations of a well-known breakfast franchise to get a better idea for the reliability of these appliances. The general managers from each location told us that they have never had an issue with their toasters even though they typically use their devices at least 20 times a day. This isn’t very surprising since toasters are relatively simple machines. They did note, however, that cleaning the crumb trays regularly helps the toaster work better and prevents them from giving off any smells.

2-Slice vs. 4-Slice Toasters
If you’re in college or live on your own, you will likely only need a two-slot toaster. These are typically cheaper and take up less counter space. However, if you have kids or usually have breakfast at the same time as someone else in your household, having a four-slice toaster can help make your mornings run more smoothly. The best four-slice toasters have dual control, meaning that the two sets of toaster slots operate independently of each other so you can perfectly toast your bread while your significant other toasts their bread at a different setting. This way if you and someone else want to use the toaster at the same time, you can. These machines are often twice the size of the two-slice toasters so you will want to make sure you have counter space available.

Checking on Your Toast
Another design feature to look for is an automatic lift. Rather than pulling down a lever to lower your bread, all you need to do is press a button. The toaster then smoothly lowers the bread for you and lifts it when it’s finished. Although this feature doesn’t affect the functionality of the toaster, it gives it a luxurious and impressive feel.How Much Do Toasters Cost?

Toasters come in a wide variety of styles but spending more is not always a guarantee of better toast. In our tests we found that some of our cheapest toasters made better toast than some high-end models. Toasters can range in price from less than $20 to over $150 and can feature digital or manual controls. Generally speaking, toasters with more cooking slots cost more – depending on the quality of the toaster. Our advice is to purchase a toaster that has enough slots to fit your favorite breads or bagels and fits your budget.

id:881